On a stretch of gravel road, families ravaged by cancer question nitrate

Most cancers ravaged Brian Bennerotte’s physique and people of many round him—his father, 5 brothers and his sister—in addition to others alongside the gravel highway the place they grew up in southeast Minnesota.

The cancers simply appeared to proliferate down the peaceable two-mile stretch of County Highway B in Dodge County, Bennerotte and his childhood good friend Scott Glarner mentioned. By their rely, 13 individuals who lived on the highway as soon as lined with dairy farms close to West Harmony have contracted some sort of cancer previously few a long time.

They know they’ve been uncovered to quite a lot of farm chemical substances of their lives, and a hyperlink to all of the cancers will most likely by no means be discovered. However Bennerotte mentioned he retains coming again to at least one factor: The excessive ranges of nitrate within the water from their non-public wells, from farm fertilizers and manure.

“That is the one widespread denominator right here,” mentioned Bennerotte, now 60.

Their “Most cancers Highway” story was first reported by Keith Schneider, chief correspondent on the Michigan-based nonprofit environmental information outlet Circle of Blue. The Dodge County water take a look at outcomes he obtained for 18 properties on or close to County Highway B confirmed a sample of elevated nitrate in lots of the non-public wells because the mid Eighties. The exams have been voluntary or taken when a property offered. All however a few dozen of the 54 water exams confirmed elevated nitrate, with some outcomes double the state and federal security restrict.

The varieties of cancers on the highway aren’t the categories medical consultants usually take into account associated and a part of a most cancers cluster. And whereas the Worldwide Company for Analysis on Most cancers deems nitrate to be a “possible carcinogen,” just a few of the totally different cancers on County Highway B have a researched affiliation with nitrate-contaminated water. These embrace non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, colon and kidney cancers. A few of the cancers haven’t been studied for a nitrate connection.

The uncommon public disclosure by the County Highway B households highlights how far the understanding of well being impacts of nitrate-contaminated water has expanded past blue child syndrome, the uncommon and doubtlessly deadly illness that drove the nation’s nitrate well being restrict of 10 milligram per liter of water formally set in 1992.

Newer analysis has proven consuming water with nitrate ranges above 10 milligrams to be most strongly linked to colorectal most cancers, thyroid illness and neural tube defectsin accordance with Mary Ward, senior investigator on the Nationwide Most cancers Institute.

A group on the School of Public Well being on the College of Nebraska Medical Heart, for instance, is learning the position nitrate-contaminated water could also be enjoying in Nebraska’s excessive price of childhood cancers. That form of analysis would not seem to have occurred in Minnesota though Minnesota’s pediatric most cancers price is second-highest within the 12-state Midwest, simply behind Nebraska, in accordance with the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention.

Leslie Stayner, professor emeritus of epidemiology on the College of Illinois, Chicago Faculty of Public Well being, analyzed information from Denmark and located proof of an growing danger of central nervous system cancers, low birth weightpreterm start and a few start defects in youngsters uncovered prenatally to nitrates in water. Importantly, these adverse health effects have been discovered amongst youngsters who have been prenatally uncovered to ranges under the nation’s present 10 milligram nitrate commonplace.

“There is a rising physique of proof that the present requirements usually are not sufficiently protecting,” Stayner mentioned.

The Minnesota Division of Well being mentioned that is the primary they’ve heard of the County Highway B considerations. Dodge County most cancers charges have not been larger than the state’s price lately and are at present decrease, division spokesman Scott Smith mentioned. Smith urged individuals with considerations to contact the state company and verify its Most cancers and the Surroundings net web page.

The company just lately set new well being danger limits for greater than 30 contaminants in Minnesota’s groundwater—however not nitrate. That shocked Jean Wagenius, a retired longtime state lawmaker and Minneapolis DFLer who advised the company the nitrate commonplace ought to be lowered. In its reply, the Division of Well being mentioned it has “rising concern” in regards to the well being impacts however the science simply is not there to vary the nitrate restrict.

Dodge County is considered one of eight counties in southeast Minnesota that environmental teams have requested the U.S. Environmental Safety Company take emergency motion on underneath the Protected Consuming Water Act, saying native regulation has failed to cut back nitrate ranges and is creating an “imminent and substantial endangerment” to human well being.

Even supposing a lot water in Minnesota is contaminated with nitrate, there’s little or no present state analysis into the well being impacts. The Washington, D.C.-based Environmental Working Group has estimated {that a} half-million Minnesotans drink nitrate-tainted water.

A Mayo Clinic group just lately studied information on nitrate-contaminated groundwater in southeast Minnesota counties—though not Dodge County. They did not take a look at most cancers, however discovered associations between nitrate and a variety of childhood maladies corresponding to persistent obstructive pulmonary illness and bronchiectasis, thyroid problems, suicide and a focus deficit problems, in accordance with their report within the Worldwide Journal of Environmental Analysis and Public Well being.

Bennerotte and Glarner need the nitrate restrict lowered. State and native authorities have to take extra motion on potential well being damages, they mentioned.

“We won’t cease what occurred, however they’ll stop one thing else,” Bennerotte mentioned.

Bennerotte lives in New Ulm now and works as a long-haul trucker. He recalled watching as a teen in 1980 when his father, Howard, was taken on a stretcher from their residence on County Highway B to the hospital. It was probably the most wrenching issues he ever endured, he mentioned. His father by no means got here residence. He died of kidney most cancers.

Simply three years later, Bennerotte was identified with acute lymphoblastic lymphoma, with a tumor the dimensions of a basketball wrapped round his coronary heart and lungs. He was simply 20. It was inoperable, and he endured 3½ years of chemotherapy and radiation. He nonetheless battles results from the therapy that his Mayo physician warned him about, he mentioned, telling him, “What cured you in the present day will kill you afterward.”

Most cancers unfold by the household. Certainly one of his brothers received prostate most cancers. One other received colon most cancers and died of Parkinson’s illness. One other brother, who moved simply throughout the highway, died of a number of myeloma and kidney most cancers, and his spouse died of leiomyosarcoma, a most cancers of clean muscle tissue. One other brother died of problems from a sort of blood most cancers known as myelodysplastic syndrome. His sister contracted MALT lymphoma in a tear duct, however survived. The one one that escaped most cancers was their mom, Marie.

Prostate and pancreatic most cancers aren’t recognized to have associations with nitrate and a few cancers within the household both have not been studied for that or analysis was inconclusive.

There isn’t a method to know the nitrate ranges within the Bennerotte household’s consuming effectively after they have been rising up. A 1999 take a look at of that effectively confirmed 19 milligrams per liter. Throughout the highway, the place his brother and spouse moved and have been later stricken with most cancers, a 1990 take a look at confirmed elevated nitrate round 8 milligrams per liter.

Others on the highway fell ailing, too. Neighbor Larry Serie died of pancreatic most cancers in 1988, in accordance with his daughter Lesa Serie. One other neighbor that Bennerotte and Glarner mentioned had most cancers declined to remark.

Glarner, 61, spent most of his life on the highway, though he now lives in Dodge Heart and works because the postmaster in close by West Harmony. From 2002-2011, a number of exams of the wells at two County Highway B properties the place Glarner lived confirmed nitrate usually round 8 to 12 milligrams per liter.

Glarner mentioned he was identified with non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma in 2006. It is not curable, he mentioned, however he is in remission and seems like a “ticking time bomb.” His mom contracted breast most cancers, though she survived it and died later of dementia, he mentioned. Glarner mentioned he was uncovered to glyphosate within the herbicide RoundUp and obtained a fee, considered one of greater than 100,000 RoundUp settlements.

Nonetheless, he mentioned he’s satisfied that nitrate performed a task. If nitrate exists in effectively water, his understanding is that there are probably different pesticides and herbicides in it, too—a farm water cocktail of chemical substances: “Simply form of every little thing.”

Such combos want consideration, mentioned Paul Wotzka, a semi-retired hydrologist in Wabasha County who co-founded the Minnesota Properly House owners Group. A personal effectively proprietor who drinks water contaminated with nitrate might be additionally consuming 12-18 pesticides, at low ranges, he mentioned, pointing to a state Division of Agriculture report.

“That is what individuals ought to be learning,” Wotzka mentioned.

Bennerotte mentioned, too, that nitrate was not the one chemical he was uncovered to. His household used malathion within the barn for the flies on their cows, he mentioned, and atrazine on the fields for weeds. Malathion is classed as a “possible carcinogen” by the Worldwide Company for Analysis on Most cancers. Atrazine, an endocrine disrupter, has been banned within the European Union.

It was all simply a part of their atmosphere, he mentioned, “We’re simply attempting to determine this all out.”

2023 StarTribune. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.