It’s as safe to get your prescription from a nurse practitioner as from a doctor

Nurse practitioners are simply pretty much as good as major care docs at avoiding doubtlessly dangerous prescriptions for older sufferers—however each have to do higher, a big, new research suggests.

Nurse practitioners (NPs) are registered nurses with superior coaching in doing most of the identical issues docs do, together with diagnosing illnesses and devising remedy plans. As america continues to face a scarcity of major care docs, NPs have been crucial to filling that hole.

One sticking level has been prescribing medicines. Many U.S. states enable NPs full prescribing authority, whereas some restrict the varieties of medication they’ll prescribe or require them to be overseen by a health care provider.

Opposition to NP prescribing typically falls alongside the strains of affected person security—that’s, they don’t seem to be pretty much as good at it as docs are.

However the brand new research, printed Oct. 23 within the Annals of Inner Medication, exhibits in any other case.

Throughout 29 U.S. states, researchers discovered NPs and first care docs have been proper on par when it got here to charges of probably “inappropriate” prescriptions to older adults. On common, these questionable prescriptions made up about 1.7% of all prescriptions in each teams.

The constructive interpretation is that seniors who see an NP don’t have any purpose to fret that their care shall be inferior, stated senior researcher David Studdert, a professor of well being coverage and legislation at Stanford College.

However, he stated, there was huge variation from one NP to a different, and from one physician to a different: In each teams, some suppliers made questionable prescriptions at a comparatively excessive charge, whereas others hardly ever did.

In different phrases, there’s room for enchancment amongst NPs and docs alike, stated Studdert.

And that, he stated, might be the place the main focus ought to be—relatively than debating whether or not NPs ought to be allowed to prescribe in any respect.

Dr. Catherine Sarkisian, a professor and geriatrician on the College of California, Los Angeles, agreed.

Given the nationwide scarcity of major care docs, NPs are a crucial supply of care for a lot of Individuals, stated Sarkisian, who co-authored an editorial printed with the research.

What’s vital, she stated, is addressing the variance in prescribing “throughout disciplines”: Why do some suppliers account for a disproportionate share of probably inappropriate prescriptions?

There are quite a few potential causes, Sarkisian stated. Some suppliers could also be unaware of tips recommending in opposition to sure medicines for elderly people. Others might disagree with the rules, a minimum of for a few of their sufferers.

And generally, Sarkisian stated, sufferers ask for a drugs and the supplier relents.

What makes a prescription doubtlessly inappropriate?

Of their research, Studdert and his colleagues outlined that based on standards laid out by the American Geriatrics Society. In a nutshell, they’re prescriptions that, for aged adults, might do extra hurt than good.

Examples embody opioid painkillers; benzodiazepines (Valium and Xanax), which may impair pondering and reminiscence and improve the danger of falls; heartburn medicines referred to as proton pump inhibitors (Prilosec and Nexium), the place long-term use has been tied to bone fractures, nutrient deficiencies and different well being dangers.

It is not that older adults ought to by no means use these medicines, Studdert identified.

“However,” he stated, “typically, they shouldn’t be prescribed.”

The findings are primarily based on Medicare knowledge linked to over 23,000 NPs and 50,000 major care docs in 29 states the place, as of 2019, NPs had prescribing authority.

Between 2013 and 2019, the common charge of probably inappropriate prescribing by NPs and docs was almost an identical.

However particular person suppliers different extensively of their practices, the research discovered—with NPs various extra so than docs. Though NPs made up about one-third of the research group, they accounted for nearly half of suppliers within the high 10% for inappropriate prescribing.

That doesn’t, nonetheless, imply they supplied inferior care, each Studdert and Sarkisian famous: NPs additionally accounted for half of suppliers within the 10% with the bottom charges of inappropriate prescribing.

For seniors, the findings underscore the significance of talking up.

“They need to really feel empowered to ask questions,” Sarkisian stated. “Ask why you take a medicine. Ask about negative effects. Ask, what occurs if I do not take this treatment?”

And for some medicines, Sarkisian famous, there’s comes a time when it is best to “de-prescribe.” As folks age, the negative effects of a medication they’ve taken for years might begin to outweigh the potential advantages.

Copyright © 2023 HealthDay. All rights reserved.