Is Heel Striking Really So Bad for Runners?

If you’ve ever spent an inordinate sum of money after operating a race to buy footage of your self taken on the course, you’ve in all probability observed pictures of your self touchdown heel first, ankle barely flexed as your foot approaches the bottom.

That’s, at the very least, in case you’re one of many over 90 p.c of all runners (together with a good portion of elite runners!) who heel strike.

As frequent as it’s, heel putting will get a nasty rap. Proponents of barefoot operating and followers of Christopher McDougall’s Born to Run guide and philosophy typically argue that touchdown heel first places runners at higher threat of harm, and that it’s much less environment friendly. This concept has made its means onto runfluencer social media, the place switching from a heel strike to a mid or forefoot strike is typically offered as being so simple as simply flipping a change. (Spoiler alert: It’s not.) There are even sneakers that claim to promote forefoot striking.

However can one thing that comes naturally to greater than 90 p.c of all runners actually be that dangerous?

Why we heel strike

The distinction between a heel-striker and a forefoot-striker isn’t simply which a part of the foot touches the bottom first. The place you land in your foot truly determines how you’re dissipating floor response forces, and what muscle teams you’re utilizing, says Kimberly Melvan, DPT, SCS, CSCS, a bodily therapist and operating coach. Heel strikers, for instance, use extra muscular tissues across the knee in addition to the tibialis anterior muscle that runs alongside the shin, whereas forefoot strikers use extra muscular tissues within the ankle and the foot.

Associated Tales

Often, how we strike the bottom is only a matter of behavior, and what feels most pure to us, says Heather Milton, MS, RCEP, CSCS, an train physiologist at NYU Langone’s Sports activities Efficiency Middle. The rise of highly-cushioned trainers has probably solely made heel putting much more frequent, although, says Dr. Melvan, since all that cushion within the heel makes it simpler for that a part of the foot to land first because it absorbs the shock.

Is heel putting actually so dangerous?

Forefoot-striking evangelists declare that it’s each extra environment friendly and safer than touchdown on the heel. Whereas specialists are divided about whether or not anybody foot strike causes extra accidents than one other, it’s true that touchdown on the forefoot usually results in a extra highly effective stride than touchdown on the heel.

That’s as a result of heel putting is often linked to overstriding, or stepping too far out in entrance of your physique. “It’s important to expend a lot power to then get your physique over your middle of mass,” says Dr. Melvan. “The vertical loading charges—these up-and-down actions—are additionally larger once you heel strike, so it’s simply not as energy-efficient.” Each heel putting and overstriding often additionally include a decrease, much less environment friendly cadence, or turnover.

There are some catches, although. Whereas forefoot putting is extra environment friendly than heel putting, all else being equal, operating in a means that doesn’t really feel pure to you and that your muscular tissues aren’t accustomed to isn’t going to really feel environment friendly in any respect—the truth is, attempting to forefoot strike once you sometimes heel strike will probably imply your legs will tire rather more shortly than traditional. Plus, on days once you’re attempting to run gradual (and sure, you should have these days!), it may be tough to keep up a forefoot strike whereas conserving your tempo simple.

And none of this implies that you could’t run quick whereas heel putting. Some elite runners heel strike, and much more transition to heel putting on the finish of a protracted race like a marathon. “You possibly can nonetheless keep fairly excessive paces in case you’re a heel striker,” says Milton, “so long as you don’t have excessive braking forces” (that means, so long as you’re not overstriding an excessive amount of).

There are potential harm dangers that include heel putting, particularly when runners are additionally touchdown with a straight leg. “That doesn’t enable the muscular tissues to soak up the elevated drive from the heel strike and the overstriding, and meaning the joints are absorbing that drive,” says Milton. Potential points embody stress fractures, IT band syndrome, anterior knee ache, and shin splints.

However operating accidents are nearly all the time multifactorial, says Milton, and even in case you may magically change your footstrike in a single day, it wouldn’t essentially imply that nagging ache would simply go away. Plus, forefoot putting can include its personal set of harm dangers, like Achilles overuse and metatarsalgia.

Easy methods to know in case your foot strike is an issue

Until you see an image of your self operating, you might not even discover whether or not or not you heel strike. If seeing a operating coach or a bodily therapist aren’t choices, listed here are just a few simple methods to inform by yourself: Try the wear and tear sample on the underside of your sneakers to see if the heel is extra worn down, or have a buddy take a video of you operating from the facet, and watch it again in gradual movement. Dr. Melvan recommends the apps Dartfish and Ochy that may assist analyze your operating type from a video.

Whereas it’s good to concentrate on your footstrike, there’s in all probability no must attempt to change it except it appears to be inflicting you ache. “It’s that previous adage: If it ain’t broke, don’t repair it,” says Dr. Melvan. In case you are having ache—particularly shin splints or knee points—it might be associated to the way you’re touchdown, and it’s greatest to hunt professional assist. However even then, it’s in all probability not only a matter of studying to land on the entrance of your foot, says Dr. Melvan, as there might be different points at play, and attempting to alter your type prematurely with out correct strengthening may result in much more muscle imbalance and ache. “The general aim isn’t to repair it, it’s to repair the opposite issues that together would result in extra threat for harm,” says Milton.

Having huge operating objectives and a severe dedication to getting sooner is one other good cause to contemplate engaged on making your type extra environment friendly, however once more, it’s not only a matter of deciding to forefoot strike. As an alternative, says Dr. Melvan, a runner would probably work on growing their cadence, permitting the foot strike to evolve naturally.

“If you wish to be sooner, possibly it’s one thing you need to take into account,” says Dr. Melvan. “However in case you’re somebody who simply likes to place in your sneakers and exit for a run, who cares? If you happen to get pleasure from it, you’re having enjoyable, you’re not getting damage, I don’t suppose it issues what your [foot] strike sample is.”